Pioneer DVR-108D - Crowning a new Champion
by Kristopher Kubicki on August 31, 2004 12:02 AM EST- Posted in
- Storage
Burn Tests DVD+R Media
We have a number of different brands of DVD+R media ranging in quality.CMC MAG F01
This is an Imation disc rated at 4x write speeds.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Both the Pioneer and the Plextor drives burn it at 4X. You can tell the Plextor tries to burn at 8X before it is calibrated down to 4X at the first quarter of the disc.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
As you can tell from the mouseover, the Pioneer does an excellent job keeping errors to an absolute minimum, even if it does mean writing the disc slower than what it is rated; the Plextor, however, does not.
Prodisc 16x
This is a Prodisc DVD+R rated at 16x write speeds.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
The Pioneer didn't make it past 4x write speeds on this Prodisc media. Maybe a future firmware will help fix this.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
There were some errors toward the beginning of the disc, but not enough to render this media useless. The Pioneer and Plextor drives have done well in keeping errors down to a low number.
MCC 003
This is a Verbatim disc rated at 8x write speeds.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Writing to this media was a bit shaky throughout, but executed cleanly.
Click to enlarge.
Hold your mouse over for the PX-712A image.
Reading the Pioneer burned disc in the Plextor shows that there was a slight glitch at the end of the write, but nothing too serious. The Plextor, on the other hand, had some trouble at the end of the burn.
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
36 Comments
View All Comments
DarthRanger - Saturday, September 4, 2004 - link
Hi Kristopher -Saw your post to my question; so you're saying Plextor has a d/l DVD RW? I checked Plextor-America's site and didn't see a D/L model there. Can you point me to a link?
Thanks,
Darth Ranger
Bozo Galora - Saturday, September 4, 2004 - link
Well well, quite a hodge podge of opinions and corrections.First of all the "retail" version with "honeycombed" casing to lower noise is not out yet. Its PART number is DVR-A08XL.
DVR-108 is the name of the drive and DVR-108D is the bare drive OEM bulk PART number.
I got that info from the cdrinfo article touted above, which does seem to be a lot more informative, and paints a lot less rosy picture of the drive.
http://cdrinfo.com/Sections/Reviews/Specific.aspx?...
After reading AT review, I had actually written a check to edazz.com for 5 of them ($89 shipped). Thanks to comments here, I ripped up the check and am now on hold again.
As far as the Plextor being $30 more expensive, pricegrabber.com has it for ~$122 at several vendors with 2 dif $30 rebate coupons noted, good until Oct.
So then I went to cdrlabs.com and saw one of the the new Liteon 16X will have a USB port version...
"Also available in an external version around October, the SOHW-1633SX offers an integrated USB 2.0 port for easy, flexible connectivity, and is ideal for users ‘on the go’."
"Fewer mistakes than usual" comment by belzer - heh heh. Quite an indictment.
I really need some DVD burners badly, but I guess I have to wait this stuff out.
And will have to take future AT optical reviews with a grain of salt - so to speak.
kcma - Friday, September 3, 2004 - link
I never read Anandtech's optical storage reviews, why? Because any burner reviews without tests on protected media is not worth my time reading. I browsed through the article quickly and once again, no tests are done on ripping and burning protected titles. If I was wrong because I browsed too quickly, I apologize. I would love to see this changed though, Maybe future articles can include these tests?bendixG15 - Thursday, September 2, 2004 - link
Okay;;Is there a diference between the modelDVR-108 asnd the DVR-108D ????
KristopherKubicki - Thursday, September 2, 2004 - link
Questar: The ridata media is pretty terrible. I havent seen another burner that burns it well either.Then again, look at some of our other dual layer tests that cant even burn the good MKM stuff.
Kristopher
mud - Wednesday, September 1, 2004 - link
"but since dual layer media still costs several dollars a disc"Can someone tell me where I can find dual layer media at that price!?
Questar - Wednesday, September 1, 2004 - link
A drive that FAILED half of the +R9 tests is considered the best drive you have ever tested?!?WTF was an average drive then??
KristopherKubicki - Wednesday, September 1, 2004 - link
Belzer youre correct, ill have that changed.Kristopher
Belzer - Wednesday, September 1, 2004 - link
Congratulations, fewer mistakes in this reveiw than usual. Here is a major one though:"CMC MAG F01
This is an Imation disc rated at 8x write speeds."
If this was rated 8x, which I doubt, it must be a mistake in production. CMC MAG F01 is the MID for CMC Magnetics 4x certified discs. If you had really tried a CMC Magnetics 8x disc, MID CMC MAG E01, you would actually have been able to try the burner @16x speed as it allows overspeeding on this media.
KristopherKubicki - Wednesday, September 1, 2004 - link
DarthRanger: I am guessing you didnt read the review.Kristopher