December '97 3D Video Accelerator Comparison
by Anand Lal Shimpi on December 15, 1997 4:22 PM EST- Posted in
- GPUs
Quake 2 640 x 480 OpenGL Tests - Pentium MMX 233 |
||
Timedemo | ||
DEMO 1 | DEMO 2 | |
ATI Xpert@Work (AGP) | 11.9 fps | 12.2 fps |
California Graphics 3DEmotion (PCI) | 1 8.6 fps |
18.6 fps |
Canopus Total3D 128V (PCI) | 19.8 fps | 19.5 fps |
Creative Labs 3D Blaster V2 (PCI) | 33.1 fps | 31.5 fps |
Creative Labs GB EXXTREME (PCI) | 12.4 fps |
10.4 fps |
Diamond Monster 3D (PCI) | 23.7 fps |
22.6 fps |
Diamond Stealth II 3D (PCI) | 16.9 fps |
16.8 fps |
Diamond Viper V330 (AGP) | 21.2 fps | 20.2 fps |
Diamond Viper V330 (PCI) | 19.4 fps | 1 8.3 fps |
Hercules Thriller 3D (PCI) | 21.3 fps | 21.2 fps |
Intergraph Intense 3D (PCI) | 17.1 fps | 17.3 fps |
Matrox M3D (PCI) | 13.3 fps |
12.8 fps |
Due to its pipelined FPU, the Pentium MMX pushes the limits of the "Low-end" of the 3D Video Accelerator Comparison, a Pentium MMX Socket-7 system would be classified more accurately, under Quake 2 at least, as being a mid-range system. The leader in this case, regardless of how you classify the Pentium MMX, is the Voodoo 2 yet again.
The ATI card does perform a little better under Quake 2 when paired with the Pentium MMX, however the new OpenGL drivers are still no reason to purchase a 3D Rage Pro based accelerator over the competing cards which offer much more for the money.
Voodoo and Riva 128 accelerators seem offer outstanding performance on the Pentium MMX, although not up to par with the Voodoo 2, they still rack in the frames. The Rendition V2x00 cards (Stealth II & Thriller 3D) also seem to do fairly well in Quake 2, all of those above choices being excellent alternatives to the newly released (and difficult to find) Voodoo 2 boards.
Quake 2 800 x 600 OpenGL Tests - Pentium MMX 233 |
||
Timedemo | ||
DEMO 1 | DEMO 2 | |
ATI Xpert@Work (AGP) | 8.9 fps | 8.8 fps |
Creative Labs 3D Blaster V2 (PCI) | 29.1 fps | 30.8 fps |
1 Comments
View All Comments
UltraTech79 - Monday, June 17, 2013 - link
This "Three Dee" thing will never catch on, Anand.