Value Case Roundup: A Look at the Affordable
by Purav Sanghani on February 1, 2005 12:35 AM EST- Posted in
- Cases/Cooling/PSUs
Final Thoughts
When it comes to value-priced cases, what features really matter and what can we do without? Tool- less features are almost always left out of a $20 chassis because, for one, they cost too much to implement, which would increase the selling price. Also, many who buy these budget cases do not really do much swapping of hardware and are mostly home users who just want something that they can put their system rigs in.
Only one of the cases has a tool-less feature and that is the Codegen 6209 with its sliding clips for the expansion slots. The 6209 also has a CPU air duct, which allows the system to take in cool air directly from the outside to the CPU, isolating it from the warmer ambient air inside the case.
The Codegen model, however, isn't the only one with good cooling features. Linkworld's 3131G can hold up to seven 80mm fans, which will greatly help cool any system, whether it be just an average setup or any high end equipment. This does come at a cost, though, since adding more fans will increase the sound output of the case overall.
Since most of the cases came with one case fan, we decided to swap out the factory-installed fan(s) with two of our own 80mm fans to benchmark each case and be able to compare them with the same hardware. We found that Codegen's 6209 performed the best in our thermal tests, since its side panels were basically large vents that helped to passively cool the system.
On the expansion side, Linkworld's 3131G had the most options to add more drives with eight total 3-1/2"; drive bays, two of them exposed.
In the end, only two of the model's held our attention as they had the features and performance results that we were looking for.
 |
We hand our Editor's Choice award over to Codegen's 6209 for its top performance in our thermal benchmarks, a solid construction, as well as features such as a CPU air duct, tool-less expansion slots, and a full set of auxiliary ports. With a price of $32, it is not much more expensive than the others and is well worth the money with the combination of features and performance it provides. |
Facebook
Twitter
RSS
58 Comments
View All Comments
DAPUNISHER - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
http://www.newegg.com/app/ViewProductDesc.asp?desc...Has side and top fans included and goes for $31. Also has room for 1 intake and 2 exhaust and good conservative styling.
DaveA - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
oh and the athenatech a602 goes for $48.50 on newegg. i recommend it over any of the cases reviewed here.DaveA - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
how come you didnt include the athenatech a602? you recommended it in your recent budget guide. it has 120mm fan slots in the front and rear of the case, a 92mm cpu duct on the side of the case which can take a 92mm fan. it has 2 usb 2.0 ports on the front along with microphone and speaker ports. its almost completely tooless as well. has a removable hard drive cage and no sharp edges.Spacecomber - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
I don't think that I can see making use of any but a couple of these cases reviewed, even for an inexpensive system. I mean there's inexpensive and then there's cheap, and most of these cases exude cheapness. For instance, I can't believe that a few drilled out holes in sheet metal can provide a proper fan vent; it looks more like what you would use for straining your spaghetti noodles.I guess that I'm also not of the school that screwless is better. I mean operating a screwdriver is pretty simple; often more so than trying to figure out how all the various clips and latches are suppose to work. I usually end up feeling like a system that uses screws, instead of these various clips, is really assembled and not just hung together.
So far, I haven't found a case and power supply (bought seperately or together) that is as good as and less expensive than the Antec 1650, which is my choice for entry level and basic systems. $55 for a case that includes 120mm fan, Antec SL-350 power supply, and side CPU air guide.
Antec just needs to start upgrading their power supplies to more models with 24 pin main power cables and 6 pin PCI-E video card connectors, but I'm talking about their cases and power supplies aimed at higher end systems, now.
Anyway, that's just my 2 cents worth. I always enjoy looking at any review that tries to focus on practical hardware such as this review does.
Space
sdfg - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
Actually, the Chenming case looks very similar to the Antec Lanboy, only steel and sans power supply.LoneWolf15 - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
The power supplies of these review units are horrible, and do not in any way represent good additional value, IMO. Every enthusiast forum I know of rates RaidMax and Powmax PSU's as utter crap. I noticed that at least one of them only delivered 12 amps on the 12v rail, not even close to what Barton core Athlon XP systems need for reasonable stability. I'm not sure I even trust the ratings on the stickers though, as cheap power supplies tend to list overly optimistic specs.For not much more than this, you can buy an Antec SX630II or SX635II case that may not be flashy, but is built more solidly, won't cut you, and has an Antec power supply. If you're serious about making a good system though, buy your power supply separately from the case. With cases, you really do get what you pay for, and the Chenming was the only case I saw in this review that I didn't think was crap.
MrEMan - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
What is it these days with all the cases being mini/mid/full size towers? Unless you put the tower under the desk, it takes up more desktop real estate than putting the monitor on top of a desktop case (which also raises the monitor to eye level, which is preferred, unless the user has bi-focals).I don't want a tower and I don't want an XPC.
I want a standard desktop case with multiple bay options which can hold either a 19" monitor or a flat panel (neither of which an XPC will do apart from a balancing act).
Besides, since heat rises, vertical orientated expansion slots are better than the heat accumulating horizontal orientated slots in all tower cases.
avijay - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
Good review. Its sad to note though for cases with a PSU, the PSU doesn't get much coverage despite requests everytime a case review is published. No indication of the reliability of the PSU that comes along with the case. Usually everyone who goes looking for a case would like to buy one with a PSU if available and it would be good to know the pros and cons of PSUs and also how they perform. Everyone knows a good PSU is as important for a stable system as any of the components. I'd really like to see how these PSUs (and for that matter some of the other well known PSUs) perform when put to the test.Possible to do a PSU roundup? If PSUs cant be covered in case reviews, please cover them separately.
Dranzerk - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
I would rather buy one of these than all the stupid expensive voltron looking "gamer" cases on the market. I saw a case that looked like someone puked up crayons they ate all over it..it was $90! lolNice article.
eetnoyer - Tuesday, February 1, 2005 - link
Still waiting on the "affordable" memory review.