AMD 780G stepping A12 update

There have been a lot of rumors circulating in various Internet forums about the current A12 stepping of the AMD 780G chipset and if it will work properly with the upcoming Phenom 9150e/9100e processors. The controversy centers on a earlier story that the 780G would only operate in HT 2.0 modes instead of the native HT 3.0 mode when a Phenom 9150e or 9100e is installed.

This statement is partially true. Installing either processor will cause current A12 boards to downclock to HT 2.0 at 1GHz speeds. While this is not a preferred setting, considering how well the HD3200 (RV610+) integrated graphics engine responds to HT 3.0, it is not the end of the world. The user can simply go into the BIOS, manually set HT speed to 1.6GHz, and the 9150e/9100e will operate in HT 3.0 mode. Not an elegant solution, but one that works fine with current 780G boards. The upcoming A13 revision will automatically switch to HT 3.0 at 1.6GHz. Boards featuring this update are expected in late May, until then, spending a minute or two in the BIOS will enable HT 3.0 capability with these new processors.

NVIDIA GeForce 8200 update

While on the subject of new IGP solutions, the NVIDIA GeForce 8200 has been enjoying a roller coaster ride regarding release dates and availability. The chipset was officially announced in January with expected availability in the March time period. We were able to snag a couple of ASUS M3N78-EMH HDMI boards last month for review purposes. We did provide a brief look at HD playback and image quality results, but we are currently in a waiting pattern for full performance results. The reason for the delay is WHQL drivers and final BIOS code. Both of which are not due for a couple of more weeks at best. We expect another driver update shortly for beta testing and then a final driver release.

In fact, it appears that April 29th will be the date for a final driver release and also happens to be the new launch date for the 780a. The current BIOS from ASUS (222) and beta driver release (173.68) results in very good performance and stability from the board, but according to NVIDIA will not be indicative of the board's true capabilities. How much performance that can be gained is anyone's guess at this point, but NVIDIA is fairly adamant that we wait for final drivers before reviewing the chipset. We have been debating whether to wait or not since the board is starting to show up in Europe and APAC.

Our current inclination is to show power consumption, updated HD video results, and maybe a few select "preview" results in our massive 780G roundup next week. We feel the current BIOS, board design, and beta drivers are solid enough to provide a glimpse at the board's general capabilities. However, we do not feel like it would be fair to NVIDIA or ASUS to provide Hybrid SLI, overclocking, or Phenom results until final drivers and BIOS code are available in April. We would like to know your thoughts on this subject as we finalize our roundup.

Speaking of roundups

The 780G roundup has turned into a marathon of love or maybe just a crazy scientist experiment gone awry. We decided in the beginning to focus on providing the standard benchmark results across a variety of applications for the chipset itself and following up with individual board reviews (Editor - That would have been wise and safe). Our 780G chipset preview and image quality analysis generated so many questions from the HTPC audience that we took a 90 degree turn and decided to provide additional results for this market. We probably will not answer all of the questions posed immediately, but rest assured we will have in-depth features and additional test results in the coming weeks for these avid users.

Right before the chipset preview, we received the final 8.3 drivers and a layout of what will be in the 8.4/8.5 releases. The final 8.3 drivers greatly improved Hybrid CrossFire performance/compatibility to the point we decided to run additional gaming tests to answer questions about IGP versus Discrete versus Hybrid CF performance. These results are enough to warrant a separate article if needed. We decided to take a different path with these boards and have generated benchmarks for the simulation crowd in Race07 and Flight Simulator X along with a couple of other games that most would place in the "casual" gaming category. A category that seems to be where mass market PC games are headed now. This in an important fact since we finally have a IGP solution that provides a decent experience in these games, especially when paired with a $50 HD3450 card in Hybrid CF.


A couple of the board manufacturers tossed in features that also warranted additional testing. J&W provided their lab favorite JW-RS780UVD-AM2+ board that features 64MB of Side-port memory and we found out quickly that it does make a difference in performance. ASRock provided their A780FullDisplayPort (gotta love the naming convention) that features our first motherboard with Display Port 1.1 output capabilities. The only problem is that we are pacing the hallways right now waiting on FedEx to deliver our first Display Port capable monitor to provide test results.

With all that said, we will have our first article up in the next day or so providing answers along with additional HD playback results utilizing Quad Cores. The middle of next week will see the review of several 780G boards with a concentration on general performance, features, and individual board analysis with a featurette on Hybrid CrossFire. In the meantime, Raja and Kris are finalizing mini-round ups with the X38/X48/790i/780i/750i/650i chipsets that will be published throughout April. At the end of April, we will have the NVIDIA 780a/GeForce 8200 release and details on the new Intel P45 and G45 chipsets. That is not all and we will go over what's next this weekend....

Comments Locked

18 Comments

View All Comments

  • Saint Nickus - Saturday, April 5, 2008 - link

    Hi Gary,

    there´s this new headline: Post cards from the Edge, AMD 780G, NVIDIA 790/780i, and Gigabyte 680i...

    But it links to your older blog:

    AMD 780G A12/A13 Stepping Update, GF8200, and More...

    Please adjust. Im so curious to read it!

  • pc780g - Friday, April 4, 2008 - link

    It will be interesting to see the performance compared to J&W board with dedicated memory on board. Also, why you, guys, ran tests against 2600XT card, should you be comparing to HD3650? And seems like nobody interested to see the memory controller performance at 1066 Mhz & 233 Mhz FSB!? Why? I am still waiting on the original article update...
  • Natfly - Tuesday, April 1, 2008 - link

    I'm really looking forward to the 780g reviews/roundup. Hopefully it'll be sooner than later!
  • deruberhanyok - Wednesday, April 2, 2008 - link

    Me too... really interested to see how the different implementations are. I'm buying a 780G board to upgrade my HTPC, but rather than just go and buy the Gigabyte board that everyone used in their articles I'd like to see what the other options are, first.
  • sprockkets - Friday, March 28, 2008 - link

    The J&W board kills the pcie x1 slot. Also, what is the difference with 780G and the 780Ga?

    I wish you would test the Intel nVidia 7xxx boards too, since they only have one set of memory banks, the performance must be slower.
  • Martimus - Friday, March 28, 2008 - link

    I'm glad that you decided to review the HTPC capabilities of this chipset, since I want to get one and pair it with a Phenom 9850 for a HTPC in a month or so. It would be nice to find out which MB would work best for this setup.
  • derek85 - Friday, March 28, 2008 - link

    The one with sideport :)
  • autoboy - Friday, March 28, 2008 - link

    I bet you could even pair the sideport graphics with a regular Athlon X2 and still get the good HD video processing performance. Without HT3.0 enabled by the Phenom, these boards without sideport are lacking in the HD processing. It would be awesome to verify if the sideport memory made it so you don't need an expensive, power hungry X4 Phenum for perfect HD playback.
  • derek85 - Friday, March 28, 2008 - link

    Just get the 9100e then, you get quadcore, HT3(1.6GHz), and good power consumption numbers. Sideport definitely helps bringing out all the goodies in HD, but I'm not saying you can't do without.
  • Visual - Monday, March 31, 2008 - link

    Yes but its B2 revision and you have to decide either to have reduced performance with a fix that you likely don't need 99.9% of the time, or accept the risk, however unlikely, that something somewhere in some usage scenario might go bad and crash your system or give wrong results.

Log in

Don't have an account? Sign up now